Man Killed By Off-duty Police Officer in Tragic Case of Mistaken Identity: The Story of Botham Jean and Amber Guyger

In the heart of Dallas, Texas, a routine evening turned into a life-altering event on September 6, 2018. 

Botham Jean, a 26-year-old accountant, was fatally shot in his own home.

He was shot by off-duty Dallas Police officer Amber Guyger. 

Botham Jean

From Saint Lucia to Dallas: Who Was Botham Jean?

Botham Jean was born on September 29, 1991, in Castries, Saint Lucia. 

A bright young man, Jean moved to the United States to further his education. 

He attended Harding University, where he graduated and began a promising career as an accountant at PwC in Dallas. 

Jean was known for his kind heart, deep faith, and love for his community.

Unfortunately, his life was cut short by a tragedy that no one saw coming.

Amber Guyger, on the other hand, was a 30-year-old patrol officer working for the Dallas Police Department. 

By September 2018, she had served on the force for almost five years. 

Guyger lived in the same apartment complex as Jean, but on the floor below him. 

Their lives had never crossed paths until the night of September 6, 2018, when a fatal mistake would forever change both of their destinies.

 Amber Guyger

A Fatal Mistake: The Night Botham Jean Was Killed

After a long 14-hour shift, Amber Guyger returned home on the night of September 6, 2018. 

It was a little before 10 p.m. when she parked her car on the wrong floor of the apartment complex.

Instead of heading to her own apartment on the third floor, Guyger went to the fourth floor.

She then arrived Jean's apartment, mistakenly believing it was hers. 

There was one key detail she missed: Jean's apartment had a distinctive red doormat in front of it. 

However, Amber Guyger was on a phone call so she failed to realize it wasn’t her apartment. 

When she attempted to unlock the door, it was slightly ajar, and she entered the apartment. 

Inside, Botham Jean was sitting in his living room, eating ice cream. 

What happened next shocked everyone.

Guyger drew her firearm and shot Jean twice, hitting him in the chest. 

She claimed that she believed Jean was an intruder in her home and that she feared for her life. 

Jean, unarmed and completely unaware of what was happening, was fatally shot. 

Amber Guyger quickly called 911, reporting the shooting. 

Despite the attempts to save him, Botham Jean was pronounced dead soon after arriving at the hospital.

 Amber Guyger in court

Seeking Justice: Protests, Charges, and the Trial

When the public learned of  Botham Jean's death at the hands of an off-duty police officer, there was an outcry. 

Amber Guyger was initially charged with manslaughter, a decision that sparked protests and accusations of racial bias. 

Jean was a young Black man, killed by a white police officer in his own home.

Three days after the shooting, the Texas Rangers arrested Guyger, but the public demanded more severe charges. 

Their voices were heard, and by November 30, 2018, a grand jury indicted Amber Guyger for murder.

In September 2019, Amber Guyger's trial began, with the world watching closely. 

Prosecutors argued that Guyger had multiple opportunities to realize she was in the wrong apartment. 

They said that Guyger was distracted by a phone call with her partner at the time of the shooting. 

They also pointed out that she failed to follow standard police protocol, which required her to call for backup if she suspected a burglary.

Instead, she chose to confront Jean herself, leading to his death.

Additionally, the prosecution brought forward troubling evidence.

This included racist and offensive text messages and social media posts from Amber Guyger’s past.

These messages raised serious questions about her attitudes and intentions. 

Witnesses also testified to hearing strange noises and possible knocks before the shooting.

This further complicates Amber Guyger’s version of events.

On the other hand, the defense maintained that Amber Guyger’s actions were the result of an honest mistake, caused by fatigue from her long shift. 

They argued that she truly believed she was in her own apartment and thought her life was in danger when she saw Botham Jean.

Botham Jean 

The Verdict and Aftermath: A Historic Conviction

After six hours of deliberation, the jury returned their verdict on October 1, 2019.

The jury found Amber Guyger guilty of murder. 

It was a historic decision, as she became the first Dallas police officer to be convicted of murder in nearly five decades. 

The next day, on October 2, she was sentenced to 10 years in prison.

During the sentencing, emotions ran high. 

Botham Jean’s family gave powerful testimony.

This included his mother, Allison Jean, who spoke of her profound loss. 

Jean’s father, Bertrum said that he had hoped for a longer sentence, though he had forgiven Amber Guyger. 

Many supporters of the family felt the same, believing that the 10-year sentence was too lenient for the crime.

Botham Jean 

An Appeal Denied: Guyger’s Fight for Freedom

After her conviction, Amber Guyger’s legal team filed an appeal. 

They aimed to either have her acquitted or to reduce the charges from murder to criminally negligent homicide.

They argued that the evidence was insufficient to support a murder conviction. 

However, in August 2021, the Fifth Court of Appeals upheld Amber Guyger’s murder conviction.

It ruled that the jury’s decision was reasonable based on the evidence presented at trial.

Amber Guyger will remain imprisoned until at least 2024, when she becomes eligible for parole, although her full sentence runs until 2029.

Amber Guyger

The aftermath of the trial also included a shocking twist. 

Joshua Brown, a key witness in the prosecution’s case, was killed in a shooting just days after the trial ended. 

Brown had testified about hearing the events that transpired the night Jean was killed.

His sudden death raised suspicions of foul play. 

Police later claimed that Brown’s murder was unrelated to the trial and was connected to a drug deal. 

However, the circumstances surrounding his death left many people questioning the full truth.

While nothing can bring Botham Jean back, his family continues to honor his legacy.

They are advocating for reform and accountability to ensure that no other family has to suffer the same loss.

Amber Guyger remains behind bars, while Botham Jean’s memory continues to spark discussions about justice and forgiveness. 

His story also highlights the urgent need for systemic change in how police officers interact with the communities they serve.

Subscribe to our free true crime newsletter here for more true crime cases like this.

In another case, a man fatally shot a drunk driver who killed his two sons in an accident.

Click here for more details on that case.