The Identification of Ruth Elizabeth Brenneman: Remains Found in 1973 Identified as Missing Pennsylvania Teen

The disappearance of 14-year-old Ruth Elizabeth Brenneman in 1973 has remained a heartbreaking mystery for over five decades. 

Known to her loved ones as Ruthie, she vanished after leaving for school one fall morning in York, Pennsylvania. 

Her family, unable to find answers, lived with an open wound, not knowing what had become of her. 

Now, 51 years later, genetic genealogy has provided the long-awaited answer, identifying her remains and breathing new life into an investigation that is far from over.

In October 1973, two game wardens stumbled upon a grim scene in the woods of Union Township, Pennsylvania. 

Hidden under a plastic tarp and brush, they discovered the decomposed remains of a young girl. 

At the time, forensic tools were limited.

Investigators could only determine that the remains belonged to a White female with long brown or blonde hair. 

Her cause of death was ruled undetermined, and with no way to identify her, she became known as Jane Doe.

The case turned cold for decades, but Ruthie's story wasn’t forgotten. 

In 2016, Pennsylvania State Police exhumed her remains from a remote corner of a cemetery in Lebanon, Pennsylvania.

They hoped advancements in technology could provide the answers they once lacked. 

Over the years, investigators used traditional forensic methods, but yet, the mystery remained unsolved. 

It wasn’t until September 2023 that breakthroughs in genetic genealogy revealed the truth. 

Investigators confirmed the remains belonged to Ruth Elizabeth Brenneman, the teenager who had disappeared at the start of her school year in 1973. 

This revelation, while bittersweet, provided her family with the closure they had sought for more than half a century.

According to Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Ian Keck, the identification process involved meticulous work.

It included interviews with living relatives, searches through court documents, and reviews of old news reports. 

Keck acknowledged the profound impact this case has had on Ruthie’s family. "It’s 51 years later, and they always had that unanswered question. 

Finally, with the investigation, we were able to give them an answer," he said during a news conference.

While the identification of Ruthie’s remains marks significant progress, the case is far from resolved. 

Questions still linger about her final moments. 

Authorities are working to uncover details about her daily life, the people she interacted with, and the events leading up to her death. 

There is a level of suspicion surrounding the circumstances of her death, but whether it was a homicide remains undetermined. 

A $5,000 reward has been offered for information that could shed light on her case.

Ruthie’s story is another example of how genetic genealogy is transforming cold case investigations. 

This technique has become a beacon of hope for countless families who have lost loved ones under mysterious circumstances. 

“At the time of her disappearance, genealogy was in its infancy,” Trooper Keck explained. “But the advancement of technology gave us the tools to finally move forward.”

As Pennsylvania State Police continue their investigation, Ruthie’s identification stands as a testament to persistence, technology, and the enduring hope of finding the truth. 

For her family, this development answers one critical question but opens the door to many more. 

How did Ruthie end up in a wooded area 50 miles from home? 

Who might have been involved in her disappearance? 

And what can her case teach us about solving other long-standing mysteries?

The search for these answers continues, but for now, Ruth Elizabeth Brenneman is no longer just a name on a missing persons list or an unidentified body buried in an unmarked grave. 

She is Ruthie, a young girl whose story is being told, remembered, and investigated anew.

Source 

Source 

Source