Chad Sutton, 16, and Melony Sutton, 14, vanished on November 23, 1992, from their home in Inala, Brisbane.
Their disappearance remains one of Australia's most baffling unsolved mysteries, with theories ranging from foul play to tragic accidents.
The Disappearance
It was a regular morning on November 23, 1992, when Chad and Melony left their home at 7 Jabiru Street, Inala, to walk to school.
Their mother, Maree, said goodbye to them when they left, unaware it would be the last time.
After leaving home, Chad and Melony dropped off their younger brother George at school and left.
The siblings did not attend school that day and they have not been seen since that fateful morning in 1992 when they dropped their brother.
It was later revealed that the siblings secretly planned to hitchhike across the country to Perth to see their father.
"It's a day I will remember for the rest of my life," said their grandmother, Jean Turich.
"The phone rang, it was a Monday, November 23, 1992. My daughter Maree was crying. She said, Chad and Melonie are missing. I think they are hitchhiking to Perth to see you".
"I was in shock - They were my little treasures. I prayed to call that they were safe but the call never came" their grandmother added.
Tragically, their journey was already a disaster without money or sufficient belongings.
Possible Theories
The mysterious disappearance of Chad and Melony Sutton has led to several theories, each offering a different explanation for their fate.
1. Victims of Serial Killers
One prominent theory is that Chad and Melony may have fallen victim to a serial killer named Ivan Milat.
Ivan Milat was a notorious serial killer whose crimes terrorized Australia during the 1990s.
He was reportedly convicted of killing seven backpackers in 1996.
Ivan Milat was known for targeting hitchhikers in areas the Sutton siblings would have likely passed through, such as the Belanglo State Forest.
Detective Senior Sergeant Damien Powell confirmed that Milat was considered during the investigation.
"He was active over that time. There’s some suggestion he was a trophy taker of his victims," he said.
However, no personal belongings of Chad or Melony were ever found in Milat’s possession, leaving this theory unconfirmed but not entirely dismissed.
2. Bullies Turned Killers
Another chilling theory involves the three violent bullies who reportedly tormented Chad and Melony at school.
According to a former classmate, Clare Snow, the siblings endured relentless torment, including physical assaults from these individuals.
She also said that the bullies extended their harassment beyond school, even attacking the siblings outside their home.
Chad reportedly retaliated with a baseball bat just days before their disappearance, potentially escalating tensions to a fatal level.
Clare Snow described the bullies as "nasty people," claiming they were capable of extreme violence.
She suggested that the siblings might have been lured into the bushland behind Inala, where the bullies and their families could have harmed them.
Since Chad and Melony disappeared around the same time as their reported conflicts with the bullies, this theory seems plausible, though unproven.
3. Runaways Seeking a New Life
Some speculate that Chad and Melony may have run away intentionally.
Their plan to hitchhike to Perth to reunite with their father suggests they were seeking a fresh start.
In April 1993, a friend called the police and claimed to have received phone calls from Chad in both Sydney and Adelaide in the weeks following their disappearance, adding credibility to this theory.
However, no one has ever come forward to confirm giving the siblings a ride.
Sen-Sgt Powell stated that although there was no reason for police to question the information, it was "highly unusual" that no one ever came forward to confirm picking up the two hitchhikers.
Additionally, the phone calls Chris claimed to have received remain unverifiable.
Investigators have also noted the extreme risks associated with hitchhiking as minors, including the possibility of being stranded in remote areas, facing dehydration, or encountering foul play.
4. Abduction by Strangers
The Sutton siblings’ decision to hitchhike also opens the possibility of abduction by strangers.
With no money or sufficient belongings, they were vulnerable to predatory individuals offering them a ride.
Some investigators suggest they might have encountered someone who gained their trust but had ulterior motives.
Chad and Melony’s grandmother, Jean Turich, has long believed they were abducted.
She heartbreakingly shared, “It’s either foul play they’ve met with or else someone’s got them… into one of those cults.”
This sentiment reflects the uncertainty and fear that has plagued their family for decades.
5. Misfortune on the Road
Another plausible theory is that Chad and Melony met with an unfortunate accident during their journey.
Given the vast and often isolated stretches of road in Australia, they could have been left stranded in a remote area.
If this occurred, their chances of survival would have been slim, and their remains may have gone undiscovered in the harsh wilderness.
These theories, while compelling, only highlight the tragedy of the Sutton case.
Without concrete evidence, the truth remains elusive, leaving their loved ones and investigators searching for the missing pieces of this heartbreaking puzzle.
Search, Investigation, and Ongoing Efforts
Extensive searches across Brisbane and beyond yielded no trace of Chad and Melony.
The lack of physical evidence, such as belongings or confirmed sightings, has frustrated investigators for decades.
Queensland Police continue to appeal for information.
They have emphasized that memories from 1992, no matter how little, might still hold the key to solving this missing person case.
Detective Senior Sergeant Damien Powell stated, “We’re ever hopeful that someone remembers something or decides to come forward after all these years.”
For their family, the pain remains.
Maree passed away at 52 from a heart attack, unable to find closure.
"I am 88 years old now. Their mum died of a massive heart attack- She was only 52 and I truly believe she died of a broken heart. She never stopped praying her babies would come home" said their grandmother, Jean Turich.
Jean Turich, still holding onto hope, continues to believe she might one day see her grandchildren again.
“I dream of the day they walk through that door and hug me,” she said.
Comments
Post a Comment