In 2018, Brandi Celenza was brutally murdered in their family home in Palm Coast, Florida.
According to police reports, Keith Johansen initially claimed his wife's death was an accidental shooting.
However, extensive criminal investigations into Brandi Celenza's murder case unraveled a chilling story of domestic violence and murder.
Let's get into it.
![]() |
Brandi Celenza |
Background: Love and a Dangerous Relationship
Keith Johansen, 39, and Brandi Celenza, 25, were a married couple living in Palm Coast, Florida.
Friends described Brandi as a vibrant woman and a dedicated mother to her six-year-old son.
Neighbors reported that the couple often appeared friendly in public, but it was a different story behind closed doors.
Their relationship was marred by financial instability and substance abuse, specifically methamphetamine, as reported by FlaglerLive News.
Friends noted that the couple’s abuse of meth often turned small disagreements into heated arguments.
Also, Keith Johansen’s temper and controlling tendencies often brought a tense and unsettling atmosphere to their home.
Prosecutors revealed that the weeks leading up to Brandi’s death were filled with growing tension because Keith believed his wife was cheating.
Surveillance footage in the couple's home captured Keith making explicit threats, including, “I’ll teach you not to mess around again. Call 911, and you’re not waking up.”
Tragically, their toxic relationship culminated in Brandi Celenza's death and Keith Johansen's imprisonment.
![]() |
Brandi Celenza |
What Happened to Brandi Celenza?
April 7, 2018, was supposed to be an ordinary day for Brandi Celenza.
She had plans to visit the county fair with her sister but sadly, by mid-morning, she was dead in her master bedroom.
Keith initially called 911, claiming Brandi shot herself in a tragic accident.
He said he was in the shower when he heard the gunshot and there was little he could do.
Later he changed his story.
He claimed that Brandi was wielding a gun during a domestic violence incident and he acted in self-defense.
However, his story quickly fell apart after law enforcement in Flagler County dug deeper.
![]() |
Brandi Celenza |
The Criminal Investigation into Brandi Celenza's Murder
From the outset, crime scene investigators found inconsistencies in Johansen’s account.
He claimed Brandi attacked him first, yet physical evidence suggested otherwise.
The placement of her body and the trajectory of the bullets contradicted his version of events.
Brandi was found in the couple’s bedroom, shot twice.
The first shot was a rubber bullet that incapacitated her, followed by a second shot with a live round that killed her.
Criminal investigators concluded that the second shot with the live bullet was unnecessary if Keith was truly in danger.
They believed the rubber bullet had already incapacitated Brandi and was sufficient for self-defense.
Also, home surveillance video contradicted his claim of a peaceful relationship, showing weeks of escalating verbal abuse and physical threats.
These recordings painted a grim picture of premeditation, contradicting his claims of an accident or self-defense.
Further investigation revealed that Keith Johansen tampered with evidence before calling 911.
Surveillance footage showed him hiding drugs, including methamphetamines consumed by both parties before the incident.
The evidence was overwhelming, leading to his arrest and subsequent trial for first-degree murder.
Brandi’s family, devastated by the loss, pushed for justice.
Her sister, in particular, highlighted past instances of Keith’s abuse, painting a picture of a man capable of extreme violence.
![]() |
Keith Johansen |
Keith Johansen’s Trial and Sentencing
The trial began in October 2021, drawing significant attention
The defense attorneys representing Johansen argued that he acted in self-defense during a domestic violence incident and had no intent to kill Brandi.
Meanwhile, the prosecution focused on the overwhelming evidence of premeditation.
Assistant State Attorney Jennifer Dunton, who is also a top-rated lawyer in Florida, described the chilling sequence of events in court.
“This was no accident. Johansen’s actions were calculated and driven by rage,”
The prosecution argued that Keith Johansen believed his wife cheated on him which enraged him at the time leading to the deadly threats.
Despite attempts by the defense attorneys to suppress the damning video clips as evidence, the prosecution presented them in court.
These clips showcased Keith Johansen’s threats and abusive behavior.
On October 30, 2021, a Flagler County Jury found Keith Johansen guilty of first-degree murder.
Johansen was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
For Brandi’s loved ones, the trial offered a small measure of justice, though it could never bring her back.
Brandi’s sister, speaking after the verdict, said, “She deserved so much better. We’ll never stop fighting for her memory and for other women in similar situations.”
Keith Johansen appealed his sentence after his conviction, but the Supreme Court upheld the verdict, ensuring that he will never walk free again.
As the case fades from headlines, the lesson remains: recognizing and addressing domestic violence early is critical to preventing lives from being lost.
Below is a video of Keith Johansen's interaction with first responders where he repeatedly lied that his wife shot herself.
For more true crime stories, stay tuned to our blog or subscribe to our free email newsletter
Got a tip about a crime? Please contact Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS immediately.
You can also see how to report a crime anonymously online if you wish to remain anonymous
Comments
Post a Comment